Check for conflicts of interest before accepting a matter

A conflict of interest isn’t caught by intuition: it’s caught by a short procedure carried out before accepting the matter. Seven practices to build one at your firm.
A new client calls in a hurry: they want to sue a company and the matter has to be accepted this week. Nobody asks whether that company, or one of its partners, was ever a client of the firm. Six months later the problem appears: the earlier file holds information that would help the other side, and the firm has to withdraw from one of the two matters. Most of the time it loses the client, the fee and the trust of both.
A conflict of interest is not caught by intuition or by the memory of the most senior partner. It is caught by a short procedure carried out before accepting the matter. Here are seven practices to build one.
1. Record all the parties, not just the client
The check must cover the client, the opposing party, relevant partners and shareholders, legal representatives, co-obligors, guarantors, insurers and interested third parties. A conflict rarely shows up under the client’s name; it shows up under the name of a partner, a subsidiary or the person who signed the contract.
2. Search before accepting, not after
Querying the firm’s records (current and former clients, opposing parties and closed matters) should be the first step when opening a matter. Include name variants, former company names and acronyms. If the search is done “when there is time”, it will be done late.
3. Tell the types of conflict apart
- Direct: representing both sides of the same matter, or taking on the opponent of a current client.
- With a former client: the new matter is the same as, or related to, the earlier one, or would use confidential information the firm obtained then.
- Through related matters: matters that look different but depend on the same facts or contracts.
- Personal or financial: a lawyer at the firm is a relative, partner or creditor of the other side, or has a personal stake in the outcome.
The firm’s written policy should give one example of each so the reviewer knows what to look for.
4. Know where the legal line is
Article 232, section I of Mexico’s Federal Criminal Code punishes anyone who represents or assists parties with opposing interests in the same matter or in related matters, or who accepts one party’s engagement and later takes on the opposing party. In addition, the duty of professional secrecy (set out, among other places, in the statute regulating Article 5 of the Constitution) continues after the client relationship ends. Bar association codes of ethics reinforce these duties. Always check the current text of the rules that apply in your jurisdiction and practice area.
5. If you find something, decide using criteria and in writing
A positive result does not automatically mean refusing the matter. It can mean one of three things: declining, asking for the informed written consent of the affected parties, or accepting with internal barriers (separate teams, restricted access to the earlier file). The decision belongs to a partner designated for this, not to the lawyer who wants the matter. Record what was found, what was decided and why.
6. Request consent with full information
A verbal “no problem” is worth nothing. Consent must explain in plain language what the conflict is, what risk it carries and what may happen if the firm has to withdraw from one of the matters. And in some situations, such as representing two parties with opposing interests in the same lawsuit, no consent fixes the problem.
7. Check again when the matter changes
A conflict can appear halfway through a matter: a new co-defendant arrives, a client’s company is acquired, an interested third party joins, a lawyer moves to the firm from another one. Define events that force a new search: change of parties, change of scope, new staff and closing a matter (to record the opposing parties in the register).
The minimum to start this week
- A matter-intake sheet listing all parties and their relationships.
- A single searchable register of clients, opposing parties and matters.
- One person who decides doubtful cases and keeps a record.
- A model informed-consent letter.
With this, the question “do we have a conflict?” is answered in minutes, before any retainer is received.
This article is for information only and does not replace professional advice on a specific case.
¿Quieres ver Iurefficient en acción?
Agenda una demostración o empieza tu prueba gratuita hoy mismo.
Solicitar demo